On November 13, RCRC, the California State Association of Counties (CSAC), and the League of California Cities (Cal Cities) submitted comments to CalRecycle on the proposed SB 54 Extended Producer Responsibility Program Plan (Plan). Those comments urge CalRecycle to demand significant changes to the Plan to ensure it conforms with existing law and prohibit the Circular Action Alliance from attempting to impose additional conditions or requirements on local agencies.
The Plan, submitted by the Circular Action Alliance (CAA) for CalRecycle’s consideration and approval, lays out the process through which CAA intends to implement the landmark recycling law, including how local governments will be paid for implementation costs and how funding disputes will be resolved.
SB 54 (Allen) of 2022 requires manufacturers of single use packaging and food service ware to take responsibility for the management and recycling of the products they introduce into the stream of commerce. CalRecycle was required to determine which categories of covered materials are recyclable and compostable and SB 54 requires all local jurisdictions to include those materials, identified by CalRecycle, in their collection and recycling/composting programs (unless they receive an exemption or extension from CalRecycle). The 19 counties with fewer than 70,000 residents (and cities within those counties) may exempt themselves from this requirement.
RCRC, CSAC, and Cal Cities have grown increasingly concerned that CAA intends to condition reimbursement for local implementation costs on new and unauthorized requirements and seeks to unlawfully limit the scope and amount of what will be reimbursed under SB 54.
In particular, the local government associations strongly object to provisions in the Plan:
- Requiring local governments to enter into Funding and Services Agreements with CAA in order to secure reimbursement for implementation costs to which local governments are statutorily entitled. Many of the substantive terms of the draft Funding and Services Agreement which CAA would compel local jurisdictions to enter into are patently unacceptable, unreasonable to impose on local governments, or specifically barred by law. Among the most objectionable are provisions that seek to: disclaim responsibility for paying implementation costs in a wide variety of circumstances; require reassignment or termination of local personnel with whom CAA has a disagreement; limit legal recourse to recover costs CAA determines are not eligible for reimbursement; and deprive jurisdictions of judicial recourse to resolve reimbursement disputes or statutory interpretation over the terms of SB 54 itself.
- Imposing additional procedural, documentation, or mitigation requirements in order for CAA to reimburse local government implementation costs. CAA’s Plan seeks to condition reimbursement on local government’s compliance with a number of procedural, environmental mitigation, and community consultation requirements that go above and beyond California’s robust existing legal framework.
- Attempting to limit the universe of local implementation costs that are eligible for reimbursement, including transportation costs, administrative expenses, data reporting, negotiation, etc.
- Attempting to restrict local governments’ traditional rights to resolve disputes over funding, contract interpretation, and statutory interpretation through the judicial process.
CalRecycle is required to approve, conditionally approve, or reject CAA’s Plan by late-December.
RCRC’s joint comments are available HERE.
For more information, contact RCRC Senior Policy Advocate, John Kennedy.
